August 15, 2002
Double-Dip Bankruptcy?
I used to like the phrase "double dip" back in the days when it meant ice cream. By now, we're all familiar with the term "double-dip recession," which is Wall Street's latest source of anxiety. This week there's a new usage to consider: the double-dip bankruptcy. That's the concern raised in an article this week in Light Reading.
"Many doubt that large-scale telecom tragedies will manage to transform themselves into feel-good stories with happy endings," writes LR reporter Eugenie Larson. "The other option is that the whole industry could devolve into a cyclical situation with repetitive bankruptcies, just like the airline business."
Yikes. The story cites a new report from i2 Partners titled "Telecom Distressed Assets: Bondholder Beware", which suggests that recent reorganization plans commit the same sin that put these companies into Chapter 11 in the first place - projecting future revenues from demand that hasn't materialized yet. The folks at i2 dub these "magic revenues."
"Revenue for high-growth, high-margin managed services assume unprecedented growth rates ... for which there is no pre-bankruptcy track record," the firm writes. Reorganizations counting on huge revenue growth in managed services should certainly get close scrutiny, especially given the prospect of a double-dip recession and the likelihood of depressed corporate IT spending.
But there are also plenty of bankruptcy plays that seek to tip the financial equation with a different cost structure. Many feature new owners picking up distressed assets out of Chapter 11 and moving ahead without the baggage of having pre-bankruptcy management still in place.
Either way, a single dip is fine by me these days. Even when it means ice cream.
Posted by RichM at August 15, 2002 05:55 PMI thought the idea of going C11 was to get out from under the debt load. Don't some of the business plans look a lot better based on pre-c11 numbers and revenue?
Posted by: Rob Kahrmann at August 16, 2002 08:04 PMNot really. For a prime example of this, take a look at Genuity. Thye emerged from chapter 11 in an okay position, but that has quickly deteriorated -- to the point where some are talking about them going back into chapter 11.
Posted by: allan at August 21, 2002 08:50 PMYour assertion that Genuity filed Chapter 11 in the past is incorrect. Genuity, formerly BBN Planet-GTE Internetworking, has never filed Chapter 11 and thus never emerged from it. They are considering filing now. Genuity said in its 10-Q filing:
"In the event either Verizon or the banks accelerate the payment obligations under the respective facility, we would not have sufficient liquidity to satisfy the claims and would need to seek the protection afforded debtors under the bankruptcy laws,"
Posted by: Alexander Muse at September 11, 2002 09:54 PM